I think foodie meccas fall into two categories: food that is hard to obtain because of geographic and logistical constraints; and food that is prohibitively expensive. Peter Luger falls into both categories. A veritable institution in New York, Peter Luger is a no-frills steakhouse tucked in a commanding building in Brooklyn. Service is sharp, but the waiters are gruff. They ask you how you want your steak cooked, but they only do so out of custom. Why would they ask you, when they’re the experts?
Peter Luger means business. There’s no fancy array of sauces to choose from. You order steak based on the number of people in your party. (A rule of thumb is #of people in your group minus one. So if there are 5 people in your group, you order Steak for Four.) The steak cuts are huge, probably 12 inches in diameter, and are served on giant platter. One end of the platter is placed on an overturned small plate, so that the juices and oil drips down on an inclined plane.
Yep, that’s bacon.
Peter Luger is not a place where you skip the appetizers. Well, at least do not skip the bacon. If this is not thick cut bacon, I don’t know what is. It is a beautiful thing: half a centimeter of perfectly cured bacon with layers of fat like a sedimentary rock. It’s like liempo cut bacon. It is insane.
Though the server’s demeanor are about as stiff as their immaculately clean and starched white button-down shirts, they live up to their name and really serve you. Pre-sliced parts of the steak magically appear on your plate, as well as scoops of the side dish. We ordered creamed spinach; and as if it wasn’t rich enough, my cousin and I stirred in pats of butter to make it more tasty.
Heart attack!
We love our fat, so we took turns scooping up the oil with the bread. Plus it really tastes great with their signature sauce. (Their famous sauce is tomato based with lots of onions. You can buy it at the restaurant, but it’s also available in local groceries like Stop&Shop.)
Schlag!
Don’t forget to leave room for dessert! Peter Luger is also famous for their schlag, a homemade whipped cream that’s very rich but as light air. I was so happy that they gave us a whole saucer of it for our desserts. You can even mix it with coffee.
The server also gave us some chocolate gold coins with the logo emblazoned on them. My cousin told me that it’s probably the most expensive chocolate gold coins ever, haha! It makes for a pretty cool edible souvenir.
Hot fudge sundae
We got two desserts, which were both seemingly simple but really yummy. I guess that’s the whole ethos of Peter Luger, taking simple food but elevating it to a whole new level of quality and taste. Just as they have been doing for over a hundred years.
I usually try to put prices on the food I blog about. But I will suspend that requirement for this entry. Because I still haven’t come to terms with how much it costs to eat in Peter Luger. A quick google would give you a ballpark estimate, if you’re really curious. Given their prices, it’s a little peculiar that they accept only cash (or their own Peter Luger credit card). If you don’t have cash, they direct you towards the ATM across the street.
Peter Luger is worth it, but some people find it a bit overrated. For me, this is one of those restaurants that I’d try once in this lifetime. Just once, because I don’t want to pay that much for steak again.